Development of Experimental Protocol
Level 8
~8 years, 3 mo old
Nov 6 - 12, 2017
🚧 Content Planning
Initial research phase. Tools and protocols are being defined.
Rationale & Protocol
For an 8-year-old (approximately 431 weeks old), the 'Development of Experimental Protocol' is introduced not through formal scientific methodology, but through hands-on, inquiry-driven exploration. The core principles guiding tool selection are:
- Concrete Inquiry & Play-Based Learning: At this age, children learn best by doing. Tools must facilitate active engagement, allowing them to manipulate physical objects and observe immediate cause-and-effect relationships. This lays the groundwork for understanding how to design tests.
- Variable Identification & Fair Testing: The ability to recognize what can be changed (variables) and how to test only one change at a time (fair test) is fundamental. The chosen tools must explicitly or implicitly guide children towards this understanding.
- Observation, Prediction, & Simple Documentation: Encouraging children to ask 'what if' (hypothesis), make predictions, carefully observe outcomes, and record their findings (even simply through drawings or tally marks) is crucial for developing a scientific mindset and the initial steps of protocol.
The 'Thames & Kosmos Physics Workshop' is selected as the primary item because it exceptionally meets these principles. It is specifically designed for children aged 8 and up, offering a comprehensive set of components to build numerous working models that demonstrate fundamental physics concepts. Through building and modifying these models (e.g., levers, gears, pendulums, cars), children are naturally exposed to:
- Variable Manipulation: They can change ramp angles, adjust weights, modify gear ratios, or alter car designs, directly experiencing how these changes affect outcomes.
- Fair Testing: The structured nature of the experiments encourages them to observe the effect of one change at a time, implicitly teaching the concept of controlled variables.
- Hypothesis Formulation & Observation: The included manual guides them with questions, prompting them to predict what will happen before they test and then carefully observe the results.
This kit provides a robust, reusable platform for sustained experimental play, fostering a deep, intuitive understanding of scientific inquiry long before formal scientific terms are introduced. It moves beyond simple instruction-following kits by providing enough flexibility for genuine experimentation and problem-solving.
Implementation Protocol for an 8-year-old:
- Start with Guided Builds: Begin by following some of the simpler model instructions in the manual. This helps the child become familiar with the components and basic assembly. Focus on discussing why each part works as it does.
- Introduce 'What If' Questions: Once comfortable with building, encourage the child to ask 'what if we change this?' For example, 'What if we make the ramp steeper for the car? What do you predict will happen?' or 'What if we add more weight to this lever?'.
- Design Simple Tests: Guide the child to design a 'fair test' for their 'what if' question. For instance, when testing ramp steepness, ensure the car, starting point, and surface remain the same. Emphasize changing only one thing at a time.
- Observe and Measure: Use the stopwatch and ruler (extras) to measure outcomes (e.g., how far the car goes, how long it takes). Encourage careful observation of the physical effects.
- Record Findings: Use the science journal (extra) to draw the experimental setup, write down the 'what if' question, the prediction, the change made, and the observed result. Simple drawings, tally marks, or short sentences are perfectly appropriate for an 8-year-old.
- Discuss Conclusions: Talk about what they learned. 'Did your prediction match what happened? Why do you think that is?' This helps solidify the connection between changes and effects.
- Encourage Free Exploration: After some guided experiments, allow the child to freely design their own models and experiments based on their curiosity. The kit's versatility supports this open-ended play.
Primary Tool Tier 1 Selection
Thames & Kosmos Physics Workshop Box and Components
This kit is ideal for an 8-year-old developing experimental protocol because it allows for hands-on manipulation of physical variables. Children build various mechanical models (levers, gears, pendulums, cars, planes) and can then modify them to observe cause-and-effect. It naturally encourages identifying variables (e.g., ramp angle, weight, gear ratio), designing fair tests by changing one component at a time, making predictions, and observing outcomes. The comprehensive manual provides structured experiments and questions that foster scientific inquiry, directly supporting the foundational skills needed for understanding experimental protocol at this age. Its open-ended nature also allows for independent design and testing.
Also Includes:
- Kids Science Experiment Journal (8.00 EUR) (Consumable) (Lifespan: 52 wks)
- Digital Stopwatch with Timer (12.00 EUR)
- Plastic Kitchen Scale (Digital) (20.00 EUR)
- Jumbo Magnifier (7.00 EUR)
DIY / No-Tool Project (Tier 0)
A "No-Tool" project for this week is currently being designed.
Alternative Candidates (Tiers 2-4)
Snap Circuits Jr. SC-100 Electronics Exploration Kit
An award-winning kit with over 100 projects that teaches basic electronics concepts by snapping components together on a plastic grid. It includes a manual for building circuits.
Analysis:
While excellent for understanding cause-and-effect and following instructions to build functioning systems, the Snap Circuits kit is less focused on *designing* and *modifying* experiments with physical variables to test hypotheses. It's more about building pre-defined circuits and observing their electrical behavior, which is a narrower scope than the broad experimental protocol development supported by the Physics Workshop. It's a fantastic tool for electronics but slightly less optimal for the specific development of broader experimental design at this age.
National Geographic Mega Science Series - Earth Science Kit
A kit containing various earth science experiments such as growing crystals, making a volcano, excavating gemstones, and creating a tornado in a bottle.
Analysis:
This kit offers a variety of engaging experiments and introduces different scientific phenomena. However, many experiments in such kits are more about following a specific procedure to observe a known outcome rather than encouraging children to design their *own* tests with manipulated variables. It's less geared towards the iterative process of hypothesizing, changing one thing, and measuring its effect, which is central to developing experimental protocol at this stage.
Kids First Biology Lab (Thames & Kosmos)
An introductory biology kit focusing on plants and micro-organisms, including tools for observation and simple experiments related to plant growth.
Analysis:
This kit is excellent for observation and understanding biological processes over time, which involves long-term 'experiments' like plant growth. However, for an 8-year-old, the 'experimental protocol' aspect of biological experiments can be slow to yield results and might require more patience than a physics kit where changes and effects are often immediate and tangible. The scope of directly manipulable variables for immediate cause-and-effect observation might also be narrower than in a physics kit, making it slightly less optimal for introducing the *concept* of protocol development within a typical attention span.
What's Next? (Child Topics)
"Development of Experimental Protocol" evolves into:
Definition of Experimental Design Parameters
Explore Topic →Week 943Specification of Operational Procedures
Explore Topic →This split divides the development of an experimental protocol into two fundamental aspects. "Definition of Experimental Design Parameters" focuses on the conceptual and structural elements of the experiment, such as identifying and defining variables, establishing control groups, implementing randomization or blinding, and determining sample selection criteria. "Specification of Operational Procedures" details the practical, step-by-step instructions for conducting the experiment, including materials and equipment lists, precise measurement techniques, data collection methods, safety protocols, and a timeline. These two components are distinct yet collectively form a complete experimental protocol.